Head of Steel: Fishing with a Steelheader

Kris Millgate

I have no idea what I’m doing. I’m okay with that because I’m with Crusty Craig. Well, that’s what I call him secretly. He’s really Craig Lannigan of Lewiston, Idaho and I love everything about his crustiness. From his wiry beard resembling steel wool to his worn hands reminiscent of a steel mill worker, Lannigan is the finest crust on Idaho’s Clearwater River. 

“I fish it 100 days a year,” Lannigan says. “I love what it gives me. The steelhead is just fantastic. The thrill I get from doing that is just out of this world to me.”

His thrill is my throw down. My frustration surfaces fast as he shows me how to fish for steelhead. He uses a two-handed spey rod. I’m severely lacking two-hand talent so I dump spey and swing the 8 wt. saltwater rod I use for fishing bones in Belize. 

“I started with a single-handed rod and with a single-handed rod you have to double haul and it’s really rough on your shoulder,” he says. “With a spey rod, it takes a lot less energy and spey casting is elegant. It’s artistic.” 

I think Crusty may also be crazy, because I’m not elegant or artistic yet I’m still swinging line anticipating a take. I don’t give up easily. Neither do steelhead. They migrate hundreds of miles from the ocean to Idaho to spawn. They’re here for a date, not dinner, but they’ll strike if you bug them enough. Dress it up all you like. You’re bugging them and I’m a relentless bugger. So is Crusty Craig with a cast that’s pretty enough for a date.

“I look at it this way, you have the lady of the river,” he says. “Sometimes she kisses you. Sometimes she ignores you. Sometimes she slaps you in the face and other times she gives everything to you. That’s the way steelheading is.”

The lady must not like girls. There’s no tug on my line. Craig, on the other hand, is a lady-of-the-river’s man. Cast, drift, two steps, cast again. That’s the dance and his gracefulness is mocking me so I start staring at river traffic. There are fisherman wading, drifting and jetting. The anglers are as varied as their steelhead-hooking strategies.

“In a jet boat, it’s the pilot or person running the boat that catches the fish. It’s kind of social fishing. I’ll probably do it when I’m 80,” Lannigan says. “Now I’m out wading. I’m in the water. I earn that fish. I put that fly in the place that I think is going to give it the most opportunity to see it and hit it. I really earn it. It’s not easy to do. If it was easy, everyone would do it.”

In a good year, he catches 150 steelhead. I’ve never caught one, but I’ve gone through just about as many cameras. If Crusty is willing to put in time and effort to catch steelhead, I better put in just as much time and effort to make his crustiness look artistic.

 

About the Author

Tight Line Media CEO Kris Millgate is a bold storyteller, but she wasn’t born brave. Millgate, an outdoor journalist born the same year as the Endangered Species Act, grew up painfully shy and afraid of beards. She spent a decade in TV news before starting Tight Line Media in 2006. With three decades of multimedia storytelling, the Emmy-winning reporter traverses the country in search of dynamic topics. She’s outgrown her shy side too. She talks to strangers daily and she hangs out with beards often.

Leather Fly Wallet

Regular price  $85.00
Regular price  Sale price  $85.00
shop now

At first, it was enough to just know where it was. Seeing it once or twice a day on my dresser reminded me both of the trip, and the penny’s potential. Finally, on the way out the door to another fishing trip, I put the penny into my pocket as a way to curry favor with the fishing gods. When I thought about where the penny had come from, I figured it might have a little bit of a fishing mojo after spending so much time in the lake. The trip was a success and the penny earned a permanent place in my pocket.

Over the next year, I dutifully moved the penny from pocket to pocket as I went about my life, making sure to keep it safe and close by for those moments when I needed a blast of luck. At times, I’d pull it out and flip it. Heads meant I was on the right track. Tails meant I needed to slow down. Other times, I’d fidget with it as I thought through a problem. Eventually, I could tell how my life was going based on how clean the penny was. A bright, shiny penny meant I’d been thinking a lot. A dull, grimy penny meant I wasn’t as worried about things. 

It was, as it turned out, a pretty great year. The twelve months that I held on to the penny weren’t always easy, but things were moving in a fantastic direction for my family and me. I know the penny wasn’t the cause of that luck. But I still attributed a good amount to it, just in case.

When I returned to Onaman Lake a year later, the penny came with me. For the most part, it was there because it was always in my pocket. But a part of me felt like I should return the penny to the lake, to give back what it had offered me over the preceding year. The closer I got to the return trip, the stronger the feeling became. The superstitious part of me knew that keeping the penny wasn’t an option. Real or not, you don’t tempt the gods. If nature offers you something, you respect the gift and give thanks. If you say you’re going to return it, you follow through. 

That thought followed me all week as I thought about what to do with the penny. I found the answer to my problem on the windowsill of the cabin. In the middle of a handful of change left by another guest was another American penny, this one from 1960. I would have preferred another 2023, but this was better. It was older and had acquired more experience than the one I had. It would do nicely as an offering. 

As I watched the older penny sail through the air, I thanked the lake for the year that had been and the one that was coming up. I’m almost 100% sure I would have been fine either way, but as an angler and a naturally superstitious person, I think it always pays to err on the side of caution. It costs so very little to give back, to honor the resource. Just about a cent in fact. 

You don’t tempt the old gods.